THE E MAGTreve de blues.- Leon DamasCompassion is my art.- Grace A. AliGod makes stars. It's up to producers to find them.-Samuel GoldwynWELCOME TO THE E MAG, AN INVITATION INTO THE WORDS OF OTHERS.TODAY MY GUEST IS MARCUS RASKIN.RASKIN:A number of years ago 1994 to be exact, a distinguished
scientist,Professor Evelyn Fox Keller held an important conference at
MIT between scientists and those who saw themselves as developing the
new area of scientific concerns.
They were doing studies on the culture
of science,what scientists did in the labs,what the implications were
etc.. The scientists took these upstarts as an attack on knowledge and
the scientific project itself. So Keller offered herself as the go
between arguing that she was sick of attacks between the increasingly
antagonistic groups.
She felt that this was destroying the university
and not advancing knowledge, Well,she made her speech that it was time
to forget about the extremes and look for a new framework which
recognized that each side had to begin listening to each other, forget
the animus and get along in the interests of the pursuit of truth which
she argued was the basis of the University enterprise and the basis of
scholarship and science.
Of course the reality was multi varied but it was a
struggle over resources,something that big science needed. The days of
the lonely inventor scientist were long past and the pentagon was out
there offering big bucks to scientific projects.
Fourteen years later Barack Obama on a much wider platform presented
the same position. There was so much to be done: give up the old
animosities,understand the commitment to the truths: that we are all
part of the same world with common problems,needs differing a bit in
cultures and styles, etc. And everyone applauded saying that here
finally is a rational man who is prepared to put his life on the line
for the rhetoric of finding a new framework of relationships,where
empathy was not a buzz word and where an American leader seemed to
admit to past mistakes and call for joint help especially from the
haves,the West. It was a version of Bush 1's kinder gentler acceptance
speeches.
And further,there was the faint sound of the cracking of a whip which
people jump to as in Thomas Mann's Mario and the Magician or in stories
where the young follow the Pied Piper to the chagrin of the parents.
It goes without saying that human rights may be important but the cool
distant style of Jack Kennedy was much more to be emulated without
Kennedy's sardonic wisecracks.But never mind these are shadows that a
man who presents himself as the new American culture armed with
practical hope will transcend.
There are other realities which suggest that Obama transcendence is
paved with disaster. In his speech to the 200 thousand he makes a
mockery of the second world war,the 20 plus million of Russians and
Soviets who died at the hand of the Germans. This cannot play well in
Moscow where that war is seared into the memory and lives of a nation.
To believe that the Cold War started with the Berlin airlift is bad
history which does not take into account the attempts on the part of the
west to freeze out the Soviets with a currency reform which would
include Berlin. But these are past matters, what about now and the
future? That is,until Putin calls Obama and the American people to account.
Those who follow elections carefully on the national level know that
truth is secondary to getting elected. And that what politicians say to
get elected is far from the realities of how they govern. But certain
statements to nations and to one's own constituencies and internal
baronies that is what is said to Goldman Sachs, labor leaders, even
bishops and university presidents do matter.
Unless he learns to dance very well he will not be able to keep the 2 percent
he needs to do what he really cares about. And at the moment
he does not seem to be sure what that 2 per cent would go to.
When Obama is rightly applauded for not
wanting to go to war with Iraq, and then follows through with garden
variety war imperialism you know the nation is headed for continuing war
and disaster. Thus, in Afghanistan sending several more "brigades" to a
nation that is not charmed by the West,its purposes and humanitarianism
will merely escalate that war.
The idea that Pakistan is to be invaded
so that it does the "right" things on its borders will not make happy
those nations who believe in sovereignty as outlined by the UN. His
putative answer will be an increase in the defense budget because we
have other "responsibilities" and little wars to dealt with. This
results in fewer funds to deal with the US's domestic problems of
infrastructure and social welfare. It is not no child left behind,it
will be all children left behind as a case in point.
When he warns the Iranians to get rid of their plutonium, that they
are not going to get a better deal from him but at the same time now
sees an opening for "moving"to nuclear abolition he quickens the hearts
of the peace movement as other new converts to nuclear abolition want to
make the world and American power safe for nonnuclear wars. He hopes to
get the French to join in the fight against the Taliban and while both
Sarkozy and Obama see themselves as speaking for the future,both have a
very volatile public including fundamentalists that have a very
different view of reality.
And of course there is the Palestinian Israeli question. Israel is a
powerful client state of the US. The purpose of the client state is
always to go beyond what the "parent" wants, And so in this case it is
the Israelis who will continue to develop settlements and the United
States will go along,thus suggesting no changes in policy- a change
which could occur if James Baker and the old State department anti
Israeli lobby had a larger voice in policy.
And then there is the economy and the subspecies of that economy
from health care to environmental disaster? Who is prepared to pay for
radical changes?
Is there going to be a surtax on food? Is this the
moment to nationalize what is and has been the
national heritage? Can Obama and his advisers jawbone the oil,gas and
automobile industry into" Priusizing" America.
If Obama becomes president at least there will be tragedy and moments of
hope because different doors will open and the voice of the citizenry
will be heard. And that is certainly true even if McCain wins and is
faced because of multiple illnesses in having a regency for his
presidency.
Bio Note:
Marcus Raskin is the founder of the Institute for Policy Studies
http://www.ips-dc.org/